Observe that Brutus makes a short, fairly simple (though elegant) speech in prose, i. e. on the common people's level, and then considerately leaves the stage so that Antony can deliver his eulogy unhindered. Why does Brutus phrase his statements rather than make blunt statements? As Cassius puts it, “the Romans are but sheep (1. With caution and gradual persuasion, he proves that he is a consummate politician using gestures and skilled rhetoric to his advantage. Brutus lets him speak at Caesar's funeral, but only after Brutus, a great orator in his own right, has spoken first to "show the reason of our Caesar's death." C. Brutus wants the crowd to learn more about Caesar's will. 8) Why does Caesar refuse the crown when Antony offers it to him? C.Brutus thinks that Antony, like himself, was one of the conspirators. How does the crowed react to Antony's speech? what does caesar leave to the commoners. ” and saying that Brutus shall become a better Caesar. ANTONY’S 14. What does Cassius mean when he says that "the fault is not in our stars but in ourselves" in Julius Caesar? Antony is very smart and uses his brain frequently during the play and Brutus … In his speech he defended Caesar and pointed out that Brutus was the liar an example Antony said is “ You all saw that at the feast of lupercal I presented him a kingly crown, three times: three times he turned it down. B. Brutus thinks that Antony, like himself, is honorable and honest. Brutus’s speech was very effective in persuading the audience, because by the end every man that heard it was saying “Live! Mark Antony enters with Caesar’s body. Both Brutus and Antony’s speeches are used to try and convert the Roman public to their side. a. Sign up now, Latest answer posted March 30, 2020 at 3:37:37 AM, Latest answer posted November 23, 2019 at 1:03:56 AM, Latest answer posted June 12, 2019 at 6:12:58 PM, Latest answer posted June 10, 2009 at 2:02:13 PM, Latest answer posted September 29, 2018 at 5:35:21 AM. Antony’s speech at Caesar’s funeral in Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar was more effective than Brutus’ because Antony used a multifaceted emotional argument, instead of relying on one assertion, as Brutus had. Antony is a master at rhetoric, meaning he is a master at the art of persuasion. Antony is gifted with the power of oratory that helped him to stir the common man. Start your 48-hour free trial and unlock all the summaries, Q&A, and analyses you need to get better grades now. He appeals to their citizenship as Romans by calling them first by that name in his salutation: "Romans, countrymen, lovers." Brutus only had one point, which was that he killed Caesar for Rome, to stand on. Brutus overlooks that the majority of the crowd served Julius Caesar the military general. He tells them, in words that have become famous in English literature, that Brutus's stab wound was the "unkindest cut of all.". He then pauses, to let the crowd speak, and he gets a positive outlook amongst the crowd. 250 Alas, you know not. A. Brutus thinks that Antony, like himself, was one of the conspirators. and the same event with very different outcomes in mind. Antony is gifted with the power of oratory that helped him to stir the common man. Observe that Brutus makes a short, fairly simple (though elegant) speech in prose, i. e. on the common people's level, and then considerately leaves the stage so that Antony can deliver his eulogy unhindered. Because of this, Antony was able to sway the crowd to his side, against Brutus and the Conspirators. He is already a man distrusted by the conspirators for his friendship with Caesar. 3) Why does Brutus allow Antony to speak at Caesar’s funeral? 2 “Friends, Romans, countrymen, lend me your ears” (ln 70) . Casca explains that Caesar was offered a crown by Antony three times; each time, Caesar refused it, but he appeared less reluctant to accept it each time. ... as the crowd is about to leave, antony makes them stay and finally rattles off what caesar left in … He explains how he loved Caesar but if it wasn’t for him dying then who knows what could have happened to Rome. Antony does not have it easy. As the play shows, it doesn't work to try to be a nice guy sometimes and a murderous traitor other times. He follows what Brutus told the crowd moments earlier, saying that Caesar was ambitious. Antony’s intelligence was very apparent throughout the play and Brutus appeared to be naive about many things. Prior to Marc Antony’s oration the crowd favored Brutus and the conspirators. Both Brutus and Antony speak to the crowd in this scene. D.Brutus wants the crowd to learn more about Caesar's will. answer. Antony says, “I speak not to disprove what Brutus spoke. Mark Antony was not a conspirator in the murder of Julius Caesar. Provide the textual evidence to support this: Proof #1--- Proof #2--- Proof #3---What is the effect of Antony’s refutations on the Roman crowd? The first to speak was Brutus, his purpose was to mainly inform the crowd why the conspirators killed Caesar. Why does he mention Brutus and Caesar's relationship specifically? Get an answer for 'In lines 175–190 of act 3, scene 2, why does Antony speak the way he does to the crowd? Log in here. Both Brutus and Antony speak to the Roman people at the funeral of Julius Caesar. Brutus seems to be genuinely politically naive, although intelligent, and reacts to situations with reason. D.Brutus wants the crowd to learn more about Caesar's will. After careful consideration, he reasons that if he speaks with the crowd first, they will agree with the conspirators and nothing Antony says can change their minds. Brutus, who killed Cesar, tries to explain to the audience why he did such a thing, and Antony explains why what Brutus did was wrong. Wherein hath Caesar thus deserved your loves? Brutus had tried his hardest to make everything go his way but he had totally given it away by letting Antony speak, because Antony did something that Brutus didn’t do which was to appeal to the crowd’s emotional side. 2 “Friends, Romans, countrymen, lend me your ears” (ln 70) . Brutus’s speech was very effective in persuading the audience, because by the end every man that heard it was saying “Live! Then, for reasons that remain questionable even taking naiveté into account, Brutus not only yields to Antony but leaves the Forum altogether. Antony speaks to the public and begins with a condemnation of Caesar himself. Brutus ascends to the pulpit and the crowd falls silent. both brutus and antony ask rhetorical questions to make points. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. THE CONSPIRATORS 12. PLEBEIANS Peace, ho! Brutus and Cassius enter the Forum with a crowd of plebeians. Brutus, who killed Cesar, tries to explain to the audience why he did such a thing, and Antony explains why what Brutus did was wrong. Brutus speaks to the crowd first. The easily swayed crowd is easily swayed. Now lies he there, And none so poor to do him reverence. Because of this, Antony was able to sway the crowd to his side, against Brutus … Does antony want to speak against the conspirators. Even before he began to speak, Antony faced two difficult problems: first was the fact that he said it under a set of unfavourable ground rules made by Brutus, and the second, that most of citizens was already on Brutus’ side. He knows that Brutus was Caesar's special friend, as evidenced by Caesar's surprise when Brutus stabs him ("et tu, Brutus"), and how he asks "and you [of all people], Brutus [how could you? Caesar and his train exit, but Brutus tugs on Casca ’s cloak, detaining him. Live Brutus! He believes that Antony’s forces have captured Brutus’s camp. Antony’s speech at Caesar’s funeral in Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar was more effective than Brutus’ because Antony used a multifaceted emotional argument, instead of relying on one assertion, as Brutus had. c. He is easily deceived by Brutus. He wants to explain the reasons for killing Caesar. In your response, talk briefly about each speaker's use of appeals. ]," which Caesar says as he is dying. C.Brutus thinks that Antony, like himself, was one of the conspirators. After Brutus and his fellow conspirators kill Caesar outside the senate, Antony meets with Brutus and manages to persuade him that he agrees with the reasons why they killed the dictator, so that he is allowed to talk at Caesar’s funeral. I will help you with the questions you have about the passage, though. Antony is using a dramatic effect on the people, first by entering on the stage with the body of Caesar, and at the end stating that his heart is still with the body of Caesar, ending his speech weeping. After the third refusal, Caesar swooned from “the falling sickness.” So many people are clamoring to hear them that Cassius takes one group off while the others stay to listen to Brutus speak. Brutus has the crowd so enthralled with him that they threated Antony before Antony has a chance to say anything. Does antony want to speak against the conspirators. Antony indirectly persuades the crowd that Brutus was wrong in killing Caesar and that Caesar's death should be avenged. antony addresses the crowd directly, whereas brutus does not. He speaks to the crowd this way in order to emotionally move them to rebel against those who killed Caesar. However, Marc Antony’s compelling discourse caused the plebeians to support him, and not Brutus. Antony tells the captivated crowd that Caesar was not full of detrimental ambition and sarcastically states “Brutus is an honorable man.” Antony brings this up when he says “when the poor have cried, Caesar hath wept; Ambition should be mad of sterner stuff:” which clearly indicates Caesar had a very soft personality and should not have been persecuted for his caring actions. He was very close to Caesar and is very angry and grieved that he was killed. Cassius exits to speak to another portion of the crowd. Mark Antony used more rhetorical questions in his speech to help persuade the Romans and Brutus did not. Unlike Brutus, Marc Antony’s speech was filled with a lot of irony, and I think he uses that method because he wasn’t allowed to speak the true in the crowd of people. Although Brutus’s speech was very influential, the speech Mark Antony gave had a quite bigger impact. After Brutus’ convincing speech, the plebeians are reluctant to listen to Mark Antony at all, claiming that Caesar was a tyrant. Use up and down arrows to review and enter to select. From this, the crowd’s reaction to Brutus’s speech is remarkably positive, with some citizens even suggesting that Brutus … A.Brutus wants the other conspirators to be shamed for what they have done. Antony doesn't become distracted. Unlike Brutus, Marc Antony’s speech was filled with a lot of irony, and I think he uses that method because he wasn’t allowed to speak the true in the crowd of people. Brutus was very honorable and Antony was very persuasive. ” , but that is exactly what he does. Marc Antony used three literary devices during his funeral oration, rhetorical question, sarcasm, and repetition, to successfully persuade the crowd. So Brutus thinks that it will be safe to let Antony speak if Brutus first explains to the crowd why the death of Caesar was necessary. Brutus and Antony are both noble people that are both fair speakers in William Shakespeare’s play, Julius Cesar. Whose servant arrives? 14) Why does Brutus refuse to swear an oath. Brutus believes that Antony is the same kind of person he is; a man who can be trusted to keep his word and act honourably. AT THE FOOT OF POMPEY’S STATUE 13. Both people spoke at Cesar’s funeral trying to persuade their audience about his death. Antony’s speech at Caesar’s funeral in Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar was more effective than Brutus’ because Antony used a multifaceted emotional argument, instead of relying on one assertion, as Brutus had. How do Brutus and Mark Antony differ in their understanding of their audience, the Roman crowd? Why do Brutus and Antony speak to the crowd in Act III, scene ii of Julius Caesar. But Brutus says he was ambitious, And Brutus is an honourable man. Are you a teacher? Immediately, Antony is able to do what Brutus failed to do by connecting with the citizens instead of talking above them. The use of rhetorical questions in Antony's speech causes the crowd to question what they once thought. 106). Antony proves himself everywhere Brutus was weak. Top subjects are Literature, History, and Social Sciences. B.Brutus thinks that Antony, like himself, is honorable and honest. Brutus and Antony both spoke to the crowd,using the same rhetorical devices to express their thoughts. Brutus insists, however, that having Antony speak at Caesar’s funeral will help justify the conspirators’ actions in the eyes of the Roman people. b. Brutus vs Antony The most predominate and important aspect In the play Julius Caesar, by William Shakespeare are the speeches given to the Roman citizens by Brutus and Antony, the two main charaters, following the death of Caesar. Due to the fact that Brutus used this word with a negative connotation, Antony follows suit. view. Brutus explains to the crowd why the conspirators killed Caesar and then insists they stay to hear Mark Antony. Mark Antony, however, speaks in terms understood by the military, by calling them first by, "Friends, Romans, countrymen." Antony was a close friend of Caesar's and Brutus did not have Antony assassinated. Why does Brutus phrase his statements rather than make blunt statements? Brutus plans to make a speech to the Roman people, outlining the reasons for Caesar’s death, and he tells Antony that he can speak afterward. 5) Was assassinating Caesar the right decision? He creates poignancy (a feeling of specialness) by pointing out the specific holes made by specific conspirators (he's pretending to know which holes were made by which person, of course)--that's why he moves to the body and draws attention to it. 10) Why does Antony shake hands with the conspirators? In Julius Caesar, why does Antony describe Brutus as “the noblest Roman of them all”? Therefore, Antony wants the crowd to turn on Brutus. He is very angry, too, that Brutus, of all people, participated in the assassination plot. A civil war is the outcome of this assassination. Brutus overlooks that the majority of the crowd served Julius Caesar the military general. Although Brutus’s words temporarily win the crowd’s sympathies, Antony goes on to deliver a moving speech full of masterful rhetoric that quickly turns the Roman people against the conspirators, leading to a riot and, later, war. Repeatedly Antony states “Brutus is an honorable man” emphatically for the duration of his speech to contradict Brutus’s nobility ( March Antony, Lines 83,88,95 ). ANTONY But yesterday the word of Caesar might 130 Have stood against the world. He begins again to speak. Why? However, by the end of Antony's … ... as the crowd is about to leave, antony makes them stay and finally rattles off what caesar left in his will. yes. 2) Why does Caesar decide to go to the Senate despite his wife’s warnings? Already a member? In William Shakespeare’s play, Julius Caesar, there is a major difference between two of the characters, Brutus and Mark Antony. What are some character traits of Mark Antony in Shakespeare's. Brutus vs Antony The most predominate and important aspect In the play Julius Caesar, by William Shakespeare are the speeches given to the Roman citizens by Brutus and Antony, the two main charaters, following the death of Caesar. For example, Brutus spoke in a detached way about Caesar’s death while Antony spoke to the emotions of the crowd by crying and talking about all the good things that Caesar did for Rome. B.Brutus thinks that Antony, like himself, is honorable and honest. However, their purpose and the outcome of their words is very different. Antony is furious that the crowd sees Brutus as a hero who has saved Rome from a tyrant. After Brutus and his fellow conspirators kill Caesar outside the senate, Antony meets with Brutus and manages to persuade him that he agrees with the reasons why they killed the dictator, so that he is allowed to talk at Caesar’s funeral. B. Brutus thinks that Antony, like himself, is honorable and honest. Antony being very loyal to Caesar is hurt by the assassination and vows to avenge Caesar. 7) What is the significance of the comet? Hear Antony, most noble Antony! Now mark him. 3. Brutus stabbed him with the good of Rome in mind, and anyone who loves his freedom should stand with him. In lines 175-190 of Act 3, scene 2, why does Antony speak the way he does to the crowd?Why does he mention Brutus’ and Caesar’s relationship… Correct answers: 1 question: Which statement best compares the two monologues? SparkNotes is brought to you by Barnes & Noble. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. Brutus lets him speak at Caesar’s funeral, but only after Brutus,a great orator in his own right, has spoken first to “show the reason of our Caesar’s death”. Since aporia feigns or pretends, Antony uses this rhetorical device by claiming, “Hear this testament-/ Which, pardon me, I do not mean to read” (Shakespeare 45). He calls Brutus and the rest of the conspirators “honorable” directly after this. The people of Rome will follow anyone which is why they rooted for Antony because he spoke last. See Important Quotations Explained Summary: Act III, scene ii. With caution and gradual persuasion, he proves that he is a consummate politician using gestures and skilled rhetoric to his advantage. Brutus and Cassius hit the streets, surrounded by crowds of common folks. Brutus stabbed him with the good of Rome in mind, and anyone who loves his freedom should stand with him. He also wanted to explain why Caesar …show more content… Antony starts off his speech the same way Brutus did, in Act III, Sc. He mentions Brutus because Brutus and Caesar were particularly close and people thought Brutus extremely loyal to Caesar, which makes Brutus's betrayal that much more shocking. And that’s what the crowd does. Brutus, was indeed one of the conspirators. The first to speak was Brutus, his purpose was to mainly inform the crowd why the conspirators killed Caesar. D. Brutus wants the other conspirators to be shamed for what they have done. 11) Why does Caesar’s will have such a powerful impact on the plebeians? Brutus vs Antony The most predominate and important aspect In the play Julius Caesar, by William Shakespeare are the speeches given to the Roman citizens by Brutus and Antony, the two main charaters, following the death of Caesar. He speaks to the crowd this way in order to emotionally move them to rebel against those who killed Caesar. After Brutus’ convincing speech, the plebeians are reluctant to listen to Mark Antony at all, claiming that Caesar was a tyrant. Brutus allows Antony to speak at Caesar’s funeral in the hopes that doing so will work to the conspirators’ benefit. ” and saying that Brutus shall become a better Caesar. Why do Brutus and Antony speak to the crowd in Act III, scene ii of Julius Caesar How does the crowed react to Antony's speech? He also wanted to explain why Caesar …show more content… Antony starts off his speech the same way Brutus did, in Act III, Sc. Brutus manages to do an extremely good job at attempting to win the crowd over but he still doesn’t manage to do it yet. 8) Why does Caesar refuse the crown when Antony offers it to him? Both people spoke at Cesar’s funeral trying to persuade their audience about his death. Because of this, Antony was able to sway the crowd to his side, against Brutus and the Conspirators. Brutus should never have allowed Antony to speak, but, as always, Brutus tries to have it both ways. Burtus makes it very clear that Antony may speak whatever good he wishes of Caesar so long as he speaks no ill of the conspirators. He tells the crowd that this was necessary in order to … —–Mark Antony fully supports Brutus as the next dictator of Rome because Caesar was overly ambitious and harmful to Rome; mutiny might be an expected reaction from the Roman crowd. While …show more content… Antony uses parallel structure to show how close he was to Caesar. He appeals to their citizenship as Romans by calling them first by that name in … TO GO HOME AND GET OUT OF THE CROWD SO THAT HE WILL BE SAFE BECAUSE HE IS OLDER 11. Brutus and Antony both spoke to the crowd,using the same rhetorical devices to express their thoughts. Live Brutus! In lines 175-190 of Act 3, scene 2, why does Antony speak the way he does to the crowd?Why does he mention Brutus’ and Caesar’s relationship… According to Brutus, who should bear the consequences of their actions? Antony “refutes” (counters) Brutus’ claim of Caesar being ambitious by providing proof three different times. Brutus addresses the onstage crowd, assuring them that they may trust in his honor. Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. Later, this plan goes awry. So Brutus thinks that it will be safe to let Antony speak if Brutus first explains to the crowd why the death of Caesar was necessary. Brutus and Antony both spoke to the crowd,using the same rhetorical devices to express their thoughts. Brutus’s mistake in letting Antony speak derails the conspirators’ cause and leads to tragedy. “Not that I love’d Caesar less, but that I love’d Rome more” (III.ii.21-22 in Brutus’s speech to the crowd of citizens). d. He does not realize that Antony is capable of threatening the conspirators. Brutus gives a reasoned prose speech that convinces the crowd Caesar had to die. brutus' use of ambitious is positive, whereas antony's is negative. He convinces Brutus to let Antony speak at Caesar’s funeral. A.Brutus wants the other conspirators to be shamed for what they have done. Brutus only had one point, which was that he killed Caesar for Rome, to stand on. Why does Brutus agree to allow Marc Antony speak at Caesar's funeral? Brutus and Antony are both noble people that are both fair speakers in William Shakespeare’s play, Julius Cesar. He speaks to the crowd this way in order to emotionally move them to rebel against those who killed Caesar. If Brutus went after Antony, he might have been the more successful one. C. Brutus wants the crowd to learn more about Caesar's will. Brutus instructs Antony to speak well of the conspirators: “You shall not in your funeral speech blame us, / But speak all good you can devise of Caesar, / And say you do ’t by our permission.” Cassius strongly objects to this plan, pointing out that there’s no way to know “how much the people may be moved / By that which he will utter.” Brutus insists, however, that having Antony speak at Caesar’s funeral will help justify the conspirators’ actions in the eyes of the Roman people. Brutus speaks in prose, demands attention, is unsure of the crowd's reaction, and uses opinion statements while Antony is poetic, requests attention, knows the crowd's reaction, and uses specific examples, making his speech more effective. Casca explains to Brutus and Cassius that, in the arena, Caesar refused the crown every time Antony offered it because each time he refused, the crowd responded uproariously. Because Antony is so good at persuasion, he succeeds: the crowd does turn on Brutus. Mark Antony enters with Caesar’s body. Antony is furious that Brutus has done such a dastardly thing as participate in murdering his close friend and even angrier that he now has swayed the crowd into believing he did it for honorable reasons. He pauses earlier in his speech in order to let the crowd know how hurt he is about Caesar's death, but here he just moves down so he can use the body as a visual aid, if you will. Brutus should never have allowed Antony to speak, but, as always, Brutus tries to have it both ways. O masters, if I were disposed to stir Your hearts and minds to mutiny and rage, I should do Brutus wrong and Cassius wrong, 135 There are differing responses to this question, depending on which character provides the answer. Brutus is clearly overmatched at Caesar's funeral, both by Antony's duplicity and oration. ANTONY But yesterday the word of Caesar might Have stood against the world; ... Antony arrives, and Brutus asks the crowd to hear him speak. What does Antony say will be the effects if the crowd were to read the will? _____ 36. Brutus quickly convinces the people to see the death of Caesar in a positive light; therefore, claiming it was to protect Rome from the ambition of Caesar. Now mark him, he begins again to speak. He then begins his attacks on Brutus' speech; he manages to tackle Brutus' points on why Caesar should die. He asks Casca why Caesar looked so sad. Due to this, Brutus’s most useful weapon is his honesty. Although Brutus’s speech was very influential, the speech Mark Antony gave had a quite bigger impact. Antony gives an emotional eulogy over the dead body of his friend. And that’s what the crowd does. Later, this plan goes awry. Antony mentions Caesar had a will. Concerning Shakespeare's Julius Caesar, you'll have to paraphrase the speech yourself. What do Brutus and Cassius advise Publius to do and why? It's your assignment and I can't write it for you. both brutus and antony describe caesar's weaknesses. And that's what the crowd does. Brutus had just finished giving his speech on what had happened to Caesar and it was Mark Antony’s turn to address the crowd and he knew that he would have to hold a neutral ground at first to gain some support of the “plebeians” in line 75, Antony says, “ I have come to bury Caesar, not to praise him”.

why do brutus and antony speak to the crowd

It Infrastructure Transformation Challenges, Hydrangea Colors Green, Self-propelled Walk Behind String Trimmer, Seasonic Focus Px Review, Second Cup Sparkling Green Tea Lemonade Recipe, Drops Cotton Aran, What Was The First Car With A Radio?, Three Banded Garden Slug, Mystery Snail Hasn T Moved In A Day, Best Bread For Bread Pudding,